Gentle, refined and warm-hearted top vs. Sunny, handsome and faithful bottom

What will happen when a straight man plays a otome game for one night?

Carl Domins is not your typical teenager he is a nerd and a shy boy from River Bridge High. He is the son of a preacher and a highschool teacher. Both of his parents are strong christians who live according to God's teachings. It's how they have raised their son, according to the ways of the Bible. Carl however has a secret, one that is considered a sacrilage by his faith. He is in love with Peter Miles, the schools popular kid and bad boy. What happens when what is considered a SIN ends up being the sweetest feeling that Carl has ever experienced in the 17 years of his life?